---
title: "How to Choose an SEO Agency: 12 Questions & 9 Red Flags"
description: "Choose an SEO agency by asking 12 questions, comparing 3 proposals on the same scope and walking away from 9 red flags, like guaranteed #1 rankings. Free checker."
url: "https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-to-choose-an-seo-agency"
---

# How to Choose an SEO Agency: 12 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

**Quick answer:** choose an SEO agency by comparing three proposals on the same scope, asking each the 12 questions below, and walking away from anyone who guarantees a #1 ranking, wants to own your accounts or won't show how they build links. The right agency names the pages it will change in the first 90 days, reports non-brand clicks and leads, and lets you leave on 30 days' notice.

By [Shaheer Ali Khan](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/about-me) - independent SEO and digital marketing consultant in Mississauga, working since 2018 - Published November 13, 2026

## SEO proposal red-flag checker

Tick anything that appears in a proposal or sales call. Runs in your browser.

- Guarantees a #1 or page-1 ranking (serious)
- Wants to own your Search Console, analytics, GBP or domain (serious)
- Won't say how links are built ("proprietary network") (serious)
- Full SEO for under $300 a month (moderate)
- 12-month contract with no exit clause (moderate)
- No list of monthly deliverables -- just "ongoing optimisation" (moderate)
- Success measured only by total traffic or "keywords ranked" (minor)
- No case study or reference you can actually call (minor)
- Plans to publish dozens of near-identical city or service pages (moderate)

No red flags ticked

Good start. Now ask the 12 questions below and compare at least two other proposals.

## What questions should I ask an SEO agency before hiring?

Ask every agency the same 12 questions, in writing, so you can compare answers side by side.

__12 questions to ask an SEO agency, and the answers to look for__
| Question                                                        | Good answer                                            | Worrying answer                          |
| --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------- |
| 1\. Which 10-20 searches will you target first, and why?        | Service + city or product terms tied to revenue        | Vague "we'll target relevant keywords"   |
| 2\. Which pages will you create or change in the first 90 days? | A list of URLs or page names                           | "Ongoing optimisation"                   |
| 3\. How will you report results?                                | Non-brand clicks, money keywords, organic leads        | Total traffic and "keywords ranked" only |
| 4\. How do you build links? Can I see examples?                 | Real local or industry sites, every link shown         | "Proprietary network", bulk directories  |
| 5\. Who will actually work on my account?                       | A named person and their experience                    | An account manager who passes it on      |
| 6\. Who owns the accounts, content and links?                   | You do, from day one                                   | The agency, or "we can discuss"          |
| 7\. What is the minimum term and notice period?                 | Month-to-month or 3-6 months, 30 days' notice          | 12 months with no exit                   |
| 8\. Can I speak to a client in a business like mine?            | Yes, with a name and number                            | Only anonymous logos                     |
| 9\. What will you need from me?                                 | Access, facts, photos, quick approvals                 | Nothing -- "we handle everything"         |
| 10\. How do you handle a Google update drop?                    | A clear diagnosis process                              | Blames Google                            |
| 11\. What will you not do?                                      | Honest limits (e.g. no map rank far from your address) | Promises everything                      |
| 12\. What happens to my site if we part ways?                   | Nothing is removed; you keep everything                | Pages or links come down                 |

## How to hire an SEO agency: 5 steps

1. **Write a one-page brief.** Your services, areas served, average customer value, current monthly leads and budget range.
2. **Shortlist three.** Look for agencies that rank for niche terms themselves and show work for businesses like yours.
3. **Ask the 12 questions** and request a 90-day plan for your site, plus a sample report.
4. **Check references.** Call one client; ask what changed in their leads and how problems were handled.
5. **Sign a contract that protects you.** Deliverables per month, your ownership of accounts and content, notice period, and no ranking guarantee.

## How do I evaluate an SEO agency's own credibility?

- **Search for them.** Do they rank for anything specific, like "\[service\] seo \[city\]"? An agency that cannot rank itself for a niche term will struggle to rank you.
- **Check their claims.** Client counts, awards and percentages should be verifiable. Named case studies with dates beat anonymous logos.
- **Read their content.** Is it specific and useful, or generic text that could be on any agency site?
- **Look at reviews over time**, not just the star rating -- a burst of five-star reviews in one month is a warning.
- **For AI search (AEO/GEO) claims,** ask what they measure. Being mentioned in ChatGPT or Perplexity answers is useful for reputation, but it rarely sends many clicks yet.

## How much should a good SEO agency cost?

In Canada, expect **$500-$800 a month** for one local business location, **$1,000-$1,800** for a growing or multi-service business, and **$2,000+** for national or highly competitive markets. Compare proposals on the deliverables, not the headline fee: a $1,500 plan that writes four pages a month can beat a $1,000 plan that writes none. Full breakdown: [SEO pricing in Canada](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/seo-pricing-canada).

## Should I pick a specialist agency for my industry or a technical SEO agency?

Industry specialists already know which searches bring customers and which rules apply (law societies, dental colleges, healthcare advertising rules). A technical SEO agency is the better pick for large sites, e-commerce platforms and migrations, where crawling and indexing are the bottleneck. Most local businesses need a generalist with a strong local track record more than either.

Already signed with someone? Use the [SEO agency scorecard](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/is-my-seo-agency-working) to see whether it is working.

## Frequently asked questions

### What should I look for in an SEO agency?

Look for four things: a written plan that names the pages they will create or fix, reporting on non-brand clicks and leads (not just traffic), clear ownership of your accounts and content, and at least one case study or reference in a business like yours that you can verify.

### How do I evaluate an SEO agency before hiring them?

Ask for a sample monthly report, two references you can call, and a 90-day plan for your site. Then check the agency's own site: does it rank for anything, is the content specific, and are its claims verifiable? An agency that cannot rank itself for a niche term is a warning sign.

### What should my SEO company guarantee me?

It should guarantee the work, not the ranking: named deliverables each month, a response time, honest reporting, and that you own every account, page and piece of content. No one can guarantee a Google position, and Google says so publicly.

### What should I expect from an SEO agency in the first 90 days?

Month 1: access to your accounts, an audit and a keyword map. Month 2: technical fixes. Month 3: new or rewritten service and location pages, with URLs listed in the report. Ranking movement usually starts around months 3-6.

### Should I choose a local SEO agency?

Local knowledge helps with Google Business Profile, local links and understanding your market, but it is not essential. What matters more is whether they have ranked businesses like yours. A local agency is most useful when you need in-person meetings or local press and partnerships.

### How many SEO agencies should I compare?

Three. Ask each the same 12 questions and for a proposal against the same scope, so the fees and deliverables can be compared line by line.

### Is a cheap SEO agency ever a good choice?

For a very small local business, a $500-$800 monthly plan can be enough. Below about $300 a month, the hours available rarely cover real page work, and the cheapest plans often rely on automated reports and bulk links that carry risk.

## Sources

- [Google Search Central -- Do you need an SEO? (questions to ask)](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/do-i-need-seo)
- [Google Search Central -- Spam policies (link schemes)](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies)

## Related guides and tools

[What does an SEO agency do? The 9 monthly deliverables and what they cost](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/what-does-an-seo-agency-do) [Do I need an SEO company? 7-question quiz: DIY, freelancer or agency](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/do-i-need-an-seo-company) [Is my SEO agency working? 10-point scorecard for your monthly report](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/is-my-seo-agency-working) [What does a digital marketing agency do? Services, prices and what small businesses need](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/what-does-a-digital-marketing-agency-do) [How much does digital marketing cost? Agency fees and ad spend by channel, 2026](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-much-does-digital-marketing-cost) [How to qualify leads for an SEO agency 8-point lead scorecard for agency owners](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-to-qualify-leads-for-an-seo-agency) [SEO packages What each monthly tier includes](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/seo-packages)

## Want a second opinion on your SEO?

Send your site and your current agency report. You get a plain-English read on what is working, what is not, and what to ask for next -- free, within 2 business days.

[Book a free strategy call](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/seo-strategy-call)
