---
title: "Is My SEO Agency Working? 10-Point Scorecard (Free Check)"
description: "Check if your SEO agency is working in 5 minutes: 10 questions, a score out of 100 and a verdict. Covers non-brand clicks, leads and month-by-month timelines."
url: "https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/is-my-seo-agency-working"
---

# Is My SEO Agency Working? Score It in 5 Minutes

**Quick answer:** your SEO agency is working if, after 4-6 months, clicks from *non-brand* searches are up in Google Search Console, you can count leads from organic search, and your 10-20 money keywords are rising. Before month 4, judge the work instead: you should own every account and get a written plan plus a list of the pages changed each month. The scorecard below turns that into a score out of 100.

By [Shaheer Ali Khan](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/about-me) - independent SEO and digital marketing consultant in Mississauga, working since 2018 - Published November 13, 2026

## SEO agency scorecard

Answer 10 questions with your latest report open. Nothing is sent anywhere -- the score is worked out in your browser.

1. 1\. Are clicks from non-brand searches (queries without your business name) up versus 6 months ago?  
Brand searches come from people who already know you. Only non-brand growth is new demand the SEO created.
2. 2\. Can you count calls, forms or sales that came from organic search, month by month?  
Rankings and traffic are means. If nobody can show leads from organic, nobody knows if it pays.
3. 3\. Are your 10-20 money keywords (service + city, or product terms) moving up, and reported every month?  
A report full of keywords nobody buys from is a vanity report.
4. 4\. Do you own and have admin access to Google Search Console, GA4 and your Google Business Profile?  
If the agency owns the accounts, you cannot verify anything -- or leave cleanly.
5. 5\. Does the report list the specific pages changed, published or fixed this month, with URLs?  
"Ongoing optimisation" is not a deliverable. URLs are.
6. 6\. Did you get a written 90-day plan, and is the agency doing what it said?  
A plan you can compare against is the only way to tell slow results from no work.
7. 7\. If they build links, can they show you every link, and are they on real sites in your industry or area?  
Hidden or bulk links are the most common way cheap SEO harms a site.
8. 8\. Are pages indexed (Search Console -> Pages) with no rising "not indexed" errors?  
Content that is not indexed cannot rank, however good it is.
9. 9\. Do you get a plain-English explanation when numbers drop, rather than silence or jargon?  
Every site has bad months. How the agency explains them tells you if they understand the cause.
10. 10\. Has the agency had at least 4-6 months on the account?  
Before month 4, a "no" on results is normal; after month 6 it is a warning.

Your score and verdict appear here as you answer.

Scoring: 75+ working - 50-74 partly working - under 50 not working. Non-brand growth and organic leads carry the most weight (16 points each).

## How do I tell if my SEO agency is actually working?

Ignore the length of the report. Three numbers decide it, and you can check all three yourself in Google Search Console and your call or form tracking:

1. **Non-brand clicks.** In Search Console, open Performance -> Search results, add a query filter that *does not contain* your business name, and compare the last 3 months with the same 3 months last year. This is the number most agency reports leave out.
2. **Leads from organic search.** Calls, forms, bookings or sales where the source is Google organic. If nobody tracks this, fix it first: without it, no one can say whether SEO pays.
3. **Money keyword positions.** The 10-20 searches that bring customers ("dentist mississauga", "commercial roof repair"), not hundreds of long-tail terms nobody buys from.

Why brand matters: for established businesses, searches for the business name are often the largest single source of organic clicks. In one Semrush study of a well-known app's site, 58% of its \~24,200 monthly US visits came from people typing the brand. Those visitors would have found you anyway, so an agency that reports total traffic can look successful while non-brand demand is flat.

## How long should SEO take to show results?

For a local business with an established site, these are realistic checkpoints. Newer domains and competitive national terms take longer.

__What should have happened by each month__
| Month | You should see                                                                        | Warning sign                                     |
| ----- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
| 1     | Access to Search Console, GA4 and Google Business Profile; audit; written 90-day plan | No plan, or the agency asks to own your accounts |
| 2-3   | Technical fixes done; service and location pages rewritten or added, with URLs listed | Reports show "optimisation" with no pages named  |
| 4-6   | Non-brand impressions and clicks rising; money keywords moving into the top 20        | Only brand traffic or blog traffic is growing    |
| 6-9   | Money keywords in the top 10; first trackable organic leads                           | Rankings flat and no explanation                 |
| 9-12  | Organic leads growing month over month; cost per lead falling                         | Still no lead tracking                           |

Checkpoints for a local service business. Highly competitive markets (law, real estate in Toronto) can take 12-18 months.

## What should be in a monthly SEO report?

A useful monthly report fits on two pages and answers five questions:

- **What changed?** Every page created, rewritten or fixed, with its URL.
- **Non-brand clicks and impressions** from Search Console, this month vs last year.
- **Money keyword positions**, with the page that ranks for each.
- **Leads from organic search** -- calls, forms, bookings.
- **Next month's plan**, in plain English.

If yours is 30 pages of charts with none of those five, ask for them. A good agency can add them in a week.

## Why is my SEO or marketing agency not delivering results?

Stalled SEO accounts almost always come down to one of these:

- **Wrong keywords.** The agency chased informational blog traffic instead of the service + city searches that bring customers.
- **No new pages.** Ten services squeezed onto one page can only rank for one of them. Each real service needs its own page.
- **Too many near-identical pages.** Dozens of city or service pages that repeat the same text compete with each other and can be treated as low quality.
- **Bad links.** Bulk directory or network links that add risk, not authority.
- **No conversion tracking.** Leads may be arriving, but nobody can see them, so nobody optimises for them.
- **Budget below the market.** A $300/month plan cannot out-work a competitor paying $3,000/month in the same city.

## What should I do if my SEO agency is not working?

1. **Secure access.** Make sure you are an owner (not a user) on Search Console, GA4, Google Business Profile, your domain registrar and hosting.
2. **Send the scorecard gaps.** List every check you marked "no" and ask for a dated fix for each within 30 days.
3. **Get a second opinion.** An independent audit takes a few hours and tells you whether the problem is the agency, the market or the website.
4. **Exit cleanly if needed.** Export reports and the link list, check the notice period, and ask in writing that no pages or redirects are removed.

Choosing the next one? Use our [12 questions to ask an SEO agency](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-to-choose-an-seo-agency), or check what fair pricing looks like on [SEO pricing in Canada](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/seo-pricing-canada).

## Frequently asked questions

### How long before I know if my SEO agency is working?

Judge the work from month 1 and the results from month 4-6\. In the first 90 days you should see access set up, a written plan and a list of pages fixed or published. By month 4-6, non-brand clicks in Google Search Console should be rising; by month 9-12, organic leads should be measurable and growing.

### My traffic is up but leads are not. Is my SEO agency working?

Probably not in the way that matters. Check which queries grew in Search Console: if the growth is your business name or informational blog terms, it will not produce leads. Ask the agency to target service and location keywords and to track calls and forms from organic search.

### What is brand vs non-brand traffic, and why does it matter?

Brand traffic comes from searches that include your business name; those people already know you and would find you anyway. Non-brand traffic comes from searches like "emergency plumber mississauga". Only non-brand growth shows that SEO created new customers, so ask for the two to be reported separately.

### Should my SEO agency guarantee rankings?

No. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and agencies that promise one often use risky links to get it. A good agency guarantees the work -- named deliverables, timelines and reporting -- not the position.

### What should I ask my SEO agency if results are flat?

Ask three things: which money keywords moved and which did not, which pages they changed this quarter (with URLs), and what they will do differently in the next 30 days. A working agency answers all three in writing within a few days.

### Is it normal for rankings to drop during SEO?

Short drops of a few positions are normal, especially after site changes or during a Google core update. A drop that lasts more than 4-6 weeks across your main keywords, with no explanation from the agency, is not normal.

### How do I leave an SEO agency safely?

First make sure you have admin access to Search Console, GA4, Google Business Profile, your domain and your hosting. Export past reports and a list of every link they built. Then give notice under your contract, and ask in writing that nothing on the site is removed when the service ends.

## Sources

- [Google Search Central -- Do you need an SEO? (on ranking guarantees)](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/do-i-need-seo)
- [Google Search Console Help -- Performance report](https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/7576553)

## Related guides and tools

[What does an SEO agency do? The 9 monthly deliverables and what they cost](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/what-does-an-seo-agency-do) [Do I need an SEO company? 7-question quiz: DIY, freelancer or agency](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/do-i-need-an-seo-company) [How to choose an SEO agency 12 questions to ask and 9 red flags](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-to-choose-an-seo-agency) [What does a digital marketing agency do? Services, prices and what small businesses need](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/what-does-a-digital-marketing-agency-do) [How much does digital marketing cost? Agency fees and ad spend by channel, 2026](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-much-does-digital-marketing-cost) [How to qualify leads for an SEO agency 8-point lead scorecard for agency owners](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/how-to-qualify-leads-for-an-seo-agency) [SEO ROI calculator Is the fee paying for itself?](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/tools/seo-roi-calculator)

## Want a second opinion on your SEO?

Send your site and your current agency report. You get a plain-English read on what is working, what is not, and what to ask for next -- free, within 2 business days.

[Book a free strategy call](https://www.shaheeralikhan.com/seo-strategy-call)
